On November 12, 1948, the international military tribunal for the far east delivered its verdicts at Tokyo on twenty-five Japanese leaders who had been charged with crimes against peace and with crimes against humanity and with the waging of a war of aggression. The findings were long. The court was made up of judges from eleven countries and sat for more than two years, and the judgment ran to thousands of pages and set out a long account of the events that had led to the war. Seven of the accused were sentenced to death. The rest were given terms of imprisonment, and two of them died in prison.
The trial followed the one at Nuremberg and shared its problems. The charge of crimes against peace was new, and the law under which the court worked was written by the victors, and the emperor was not charged, and a number of the people who had ordered or carried out the worst acts were never brought before it, and some of the worst cases, including the killing of civilians at Nanjing and the medical experiments on prisoners, were dealt with in separate trials or not at all. The record was uneven. The defence argued that the court had no right to try the leaders of a sovereign state, and that argument was rejected.
A number of the people convicted were released in the 1950s, and some of them later held high office in Japan, and one became foreign minister and another became prime minister, and the men executed in 1948 were honoured at a shrine near Tokyo in 1978, which has been a source of friction with the countries that suffered under Japanese rule. The anger is real. The judgment has been used in the arguments inside Japan about the war, and its findings have been attacked by writers who hold that the country was defending itself, and the dispute has gone on through every generation since.
The tribunal also signed death sentences on men who were tried in other courts, and the trials of lesser figures went on for years in several countries. The record is a written account of a period, and much of what happened is known because of it. The question it left open was whether a court set up by the winners could settle the history of a war, and the argument about that has not been answered.