📅 Historical.Today Today in History

November 21, 1953: A Famous Skull Turns Out to Be a Fake

The Natural History Museum in London declared the Piltdown Man skull a hoax, forty years after it was found.

The Piltdown Man Is Declared a Hoax

📅November 21, 1953
🔖Archaeology🔖Discoveries🔖Public Opinion
Summary

On November 21, 1953, the Natural History Museum in London announced that the Piltdown Man, a skull found in Sussex in 1912 and long held to be a key fossil in human origins, was a fraud. Tests showed that the jaw came from an ape and that the bones had been treated to look old. The find had been used for forty years as evidence in the debate over how humans had evolved.

On November 21, 1953, the Natural History Museum in London announced that the Piltdown Man was a fraud, and the skull had been found in a gravel pit in Sussex in 1912, and it had been presented as a missing link between apes and humans, and for forty years it had been treated as one of the most important fossils in the world. That fit the mood. The find was welcomed because it seemed to show that a large brain had come before other human traits, and it matched the thinking of the time, and it gave British scholars a claim to a central place in the story of human origins.

Doubts had been raised from the start by some scholars, and the teeth had been filed down to look worn, and the bones had been stained to match the colour of the gravel, and the jaw came from an ape while the skull was human. The fraud was clear. New tests in the early 1950s used methods that had not existed in 1912, and they measured the age of the material and showed the parts did not belong together, and the museum set out the findings in a report. No one has ever been proved to have made the forgery, though several names have been put forward.

The museum kept the bones. The hoax is remembered as a warning about how a discovery can be shaped by what people expect to find, and it is taught in courses on how science corrects itself, and the case did harm to the standing of British work on early humans for a time, and it delayed the acceptance of finds made in Africa that proved far older, and the true story of human origins was worked out from those other sites.