📅 Historical.Today Today in History

November 8, 2002: A Last Chance, and a Divided Council

The Security Council adopted resolution 1441, giving Iraq a final chance to give up banned weapons.

The Security Council Adopts Resolution 1441

📅November 8, 2002
⛳Iraq⛳United Kingdom⛳United States
📖Diplomacy
🔖International Law🔖United Nations🔖Weapons
Summary

On November 8, 2002, the United Nations Security Council adopted resolution 1441 by a unanimous vote, giving Iraq a final chance to give up the weapons of mass destruction it was said to hold and threatening serious consequences if it did not. The inspections that followed found none, and the council split over whether force was allowed.

On November 8, 2002, the United Nations Security Council adopted resolution 1441 by a vote of fifteen to nothing, and the text gave Iraq a final opportunity to give up the weapons of mass destruction that Britain and the United States said it held, and it required the government to give a full account of its weapons programmes and to accept inspectors without conditions. The vote was unanimous. The wording was argued over for weeks before it was agreed, and the phrase about serious consequences was left vague on purpose so that both sides could read into it what they wanted.

The inspections began later in the month under Hans Blix, and the teams worked in the country for three months and reported that they had found no such weapons, and that Iraq had not given a full account of some of its earlier work. The reports were mixed. The United States and Britain said the failure to account for the materials was itself a breach, and France and Russia and Germany held that the inspectors needed more time and that the resolution did not by itself permit an attack.

The argument in the council through the winter and the spring of 2003 was about whether resolution 1441 and the earlier resolutions on Iraq gave a legal base for war. The majority of the members held that they did not and that a second resolution was needed. The demand was dropped. The United States and Britain went to war in March 2003 without it, and the invasion was carried out with the support of a smaller group of states than in 1991, and no weapons of mass destruction were found afterwards.

The episode did lasting damage to the standing of the council and to the argument that a great power would be held to its rules. It also showed how a text drawn up to hold a middle ground can be read in opposite ways, and the phrase about serious consequences has since been cited in other disputes as an example of what a resolution should not leave open. The record is debated. The inspectors left Iraq in March 2003, and the question of what the country held was settled by the occupation rather than by the council.